Roommates and insurance: A quick guide to renters’ coverage

Living with roommates can be fun — shared laughs, pizza night, and late-night conversations. But they can also be a hassle — like keeping to a rotating schedule for who unloads the dishwasher and who takes out the trash. 

But, amid all this togetherness, it’s important to talk about the practical part of living together—especially the sometimes forgotten topic of renters’ insurance, why it’s important, what it covers, and how to make sure you and your roommates are adequately protected.

Understanding renters’ insurance

Before we get into the nitty-gritty of how renters’ insurance functions in a shared living space, let’s look at the basics. Basically, renters’ insurance is there to safeguard your possessions in case of unexpected events — think theft, fire, or other covered disasters. The landlord’s insurance usually takes care of the structure of the building itself, but it doesn’t stretch to cover your personal belongings inside.

So, if you’ve got roommates, each of you likely has your own valuables — laptops, furniture, gaming systems, clothing and so on. Renters’ insurance is made to provide financial assistance when, in the unfortunate aftermath of a covered incident, you need to replace or repair your belongings. But your policy won’t always protect your roommate’s stuff — and it might not be a good idea to go that route altogether.

Why roommates need their own renters’ insurance

It’s a common misconception among roommates that a single renters’ insurance policy automatically covers everyone in the household. 

Renters’ insurance is an individualized protection system typically designed to cover the belongings of the policyholder — the person whose name is on the policy. 

In some situations, you can add a person you have a relationship with, like a girlfriend or boyfriend, but the cost might increase (unlike when a single renters’ policy covers a married couple or a couple in a civil union.)

Here’s an example: 

  • Let’s look at Sarah and her roommate, John. The two have lived in the same apartment for two years but are not a couple. 
  • Sarah has a renters’ insurance policy, but John doesn’t. They return home from their respective jobs one day and find their apartment has been broken into.
  • Sarah’s laptop was stolen, and her renters’ insurance policy will kick in to cover the loss. 
  • However, John’s camera was also stolen. Since his name is not on the policy, John would need his own renters’ insurance policy to file a claim. 

This brings us to an important point: communication. Before moving in together — or taking on a new roommate — have a candid conversation about the importance of renters’ insurance and the need for each person to have their own policy. It’s a proactive step that can save a lot of headaches down the line.

Understanding coverage: What’s included?

Renters’ insurance typically covers a range of “perils” — the term insurance providers use for covered causes of damage or loss. Here are some common perils covered by renters’ insurance:

  • Fire and Smoke Damage: If your belongings are damaged or destroyed due to a fire or smoke, renters’ insurance can help cover the replacement cost.
  • Theft: If your personal items are stolen, renters’ insurance can compensate for the value of the stolen items up to your policy limit.
  • Vandalism: Malicious acts such as vandalism that result in damage to your belongings are usually covered.
  • Water Damage: In some cases, renters’ insurance may cover water damage caused by burst pipes, leaking appliances, or other covered events.
  • Liability Coverage: If someone is injured in your rented space and you are found legally responsible, renters’ insurance can help cover medical expenses and legal fees.

It’s really important to read your policy carefully to understand the specific events it covers as well as any exclusions. 

Some basic renters’ insurance policies might not cover specific items, like valuable jewelry, antiques or high-end electronics. You might need additional coverage options if you have those kinds of items in your closets. 

Also, situations like floods and earthquakes require additional coverage and may not be worth it if your belongings aren’t so valuable.

Determining coverage limits

Renters’ insurance comes with coverage limits, the maximum amount the policy will pay out for a covered loss. Make sure to figure out how much your things are worth and pick a coverage limit that adequately protects them. 

Creating a home inventory — a detailed list of your possessions along with their estimated value — can help determine the appropriate coverage level. Remember that you can’t make claims for items you don’t own, so each roommate should take out a policy with coverage limits that align with their individual possessions. We can help you figure this out as well. 

What if you’re moving into someone else’s place?

Maybe you’re not the person whose name is on the lease; you’re the roommate. If you move into someone else’s apartment and they say they’ll put you on their renter’s policy, be cautious. 

Going for the easy and cheap option has risks, especially for two people — even longtime friends — sharing a place. Some policies won’t allow this, and others do, for a fee. Additionally, this isn’t permitted in every state. 

Plus, the policyholder can remove the non-policyholder at any time without notice to the person removed. Even if everything is legit, sorting out who gets what from a claim can get pretty tricky. So go in with your eyes open and consider having your own policy.

Sharing expenses: Renters’ insurance and roommates

While renters’ insurance is a personal choice, its financial implications can have a collective impact on your living situation. Let’s break down how expenses related to renters’ insurance can be navigated in a shared space:

  • Individual Responsibility: To ensure everyone’s belongings are individually protected, each roommate should be responsible for getting their own renters’ insurance policy. Doing so makes it easy to transfer a policy to a new address should you decide to rent your own place or move in with someone else.
  • Cost Sharing: While renters’ insurance is a personal expense, roommates can explore cost-sharing arrangements. For example, you could consider splitting the cost of a shared renters’ insurance policy for common areas or shared items — like a sofa or a washer/dryer unit you both chipped in for.
  • Liability Coverage: The liability coverage aspect of renters’ insurance benefits everyone in the household. In the event of an accident in the shared space, this coverage can protect all roommates.

Roommate dynamics and open communication

Before moving in together, get a feel for what you and your roommate(s) prefer from a financial perspective. Have a house meeting to discuss the logistics of rent and utilities and the importance of renters’ insurance. 

One person may not have anything worth insuring, while the other might. Discussing this upfront can prevent misunderstandings later on: establishing clear expectations regarding who is responsible for what and how expenses will be shared is important.

​​To avoid future confusion and conflicts, make sure everyone sees eye-to-eye on the need for individual insurance policies. It might help to set up a shared Google Folder where roommates can upload proof of their renters’ insurance. This keeps things clear and provides a quick reference in case of emergencies.

Protecting the stuff in your (rented) home

Remember, having renters’ insurance is not just about protecting laptops and furniture; it’s about creating a secure feeling for your home, whether you’re sharing it or going solo. 

So, before taking on roommates or signing a lease with a friend, take a moment to check out renters’ insurance and ask questions about how it works — it’s a small expense for some priceless peace of mind. 

When you’re ready, give us a shout. We’re happy to help!


Stay updated on our latest insurance advice and news by subscribing to our newsletter.

See what you could save

Don't let potential savings pass you by! Let us reshop insurance for you.

Share on Social